Top 10 Best Organic Pacifiers in 2020

May 29, 2020

A pacifier is a teething ring or rubber that resembles a mother’s teat. It soothes a baby, making him feel comfortable as he sucks its nipple. Besides, they are a great aid during teething to keep your baby calm and soothed. With something that goes into your child’s mouth, you want to be sure it’s all natural and safe for your child. With so many great non-toxic options out there, read on for the best organic pacifiers for you to choose from.

Choose a non-toxic organic pacifier that won’t harm your baby. For this, consider what it’s made of, the most common chemical-free options being silicone or natural rubber. Personally, I find silicone pacifiers more convenient for my baby as they are soft, hypoallergenic and dishwasher safe. Also, they often last longer than natural rubber.

Apart from material, you may also want to consider what type of pacifier suits your baby. I find one-piece pacifiers safer and easier to clean than two-piece designs.



How Do Pacifiers Comfort Babies?

Babies usually have a sucking motion and response that calms and soothes them. But they often tend to continue sucking even when they aren’t hungry to keep them happy. So when you introduce a pacifier, your baby sucks its nipple as if it’s mother’s breast and this helps baby calms down.


Does My Baby Need a Pacifier?

A pacifier isn’t essential, but it really depends on your child. It does have a few benefits and drawbacks in terms of health. It helps in reducing the risk of sudden infant death syndrome, which occurs when baby experiences deep sleep. Besides, it helps to calm the baby if he likes sucking while not eating.


Do I Need to Get BPA Free Pacifier?

Yes, absolutely. I cannot stress this enough. A BPA free pacifier is very important for your baby. The great news is that almost all natural pacifiers don’t contain BPA. Using a chemical free pacifier prevents harmful effects on your baby’s brain and prostate gland. If you aren’t too sure of the pacifier material you are using, don’t sanitize it in a dishwasher, as it might lead to chemical leaching.


How to Choose the Best Pacifier for My Baby?

While choosing your baby pacifier, consider the following;

  • The age of the baby: Baby pacifiers range from 0 – 6 months, 6+ months and 18+ months thus buy following your baby’s age.
  • Airflow in the shield: Choose a pacifier with holes to allow free air circulation so that your baby won’t have irritation.
  • Design: Pacifiers are either two or one piece. Consider one piece as they’re very hygienic having no cracks to hide bacteria.
  • The nipple material: Choose a chemical free pacifier that won’t harm your baby.
  • Size of the shield: It should be enough to avoid chocking.


Pros of Using Pacifier

  • It helps in satisfying your baby’s suck reflex as it won’t fill the belly like milk does.
  • Sucking pacifier helps reduce sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS).
  • It soothes baby keeping him happy.
  • Top organic pacifiers help restrict your baby from sucking fingers and items he come in contact.
  • It helps in reducing the pressure in baby’s ears in a noisy environment like on a plane.


Cons of Using Pacifier

  • Slightly increases the risk of having dental problems.
  • It might cause inner ear infection, especially at an early age when baby sleeps deeply.
  • When baby gets accustomed to a pacifier, there is a small likelihood of losing interest in breastfeeding.


Top 10 Best Organic Pacifiers in 2020


1. Hevea Pacifiers



Made in: Malaysia.

Hevea pacifiers come in a great grown design with a cheery round teat. They’re one of the best organic pacifiers that suit bottle-fed babies. It has a similar nipple to baby bottles. The pacifier is natural without any additional color pigmentation.

It has a butterfly ergonomic shape, so your baby’s chin and nose are free.

  • 100% natural rubber.
  • Functional teat.
  • Plastic-free.


What I love about it

  • Strong to withstand baby bites.
  • It’s free from BPA and Phthalate.
  • Available sizes for baby are from 0-3 months and 3-36 months.


Something to keep in mind

  • Changes color during sanitation.




2. Ummy Pacifiers


Made in: Italy.

It has 100% natural rubber which is soft than silicone thus suitable for the baby. The pacifier shield is significant. So, it offers comforts to a baby as well as stimulating breastfeeding. Besides, it one-piece orthodontic design without joints, thus easy to maintain hygiene.

  • It is from natural rubber.
  • Its round design without joints prevents bacteria and dirt accumulation.
  • It has large air holes, thus minimal cases of skin irritation.


What I love about it

  • It comes in different sizes.
  • Its one-piece design thus it doesn’t harbor dirt.
  • It’s the best organic pacifier made from pure rubber.


Something to keep in mind

  • Expensive.
  • Not compatible with the dishwasher.




3. Ecopiggy Ecopacifiers



Made in: Malaysia.

Ecopacifier is one of the best non-toxic and organic pacifier made from pure rubber. It has a round shield that touches the baby’s nose calmly—thus contributing to a soothing feeling of breastfeeding. The single-piece design prevents your baby from choking hazard.

  • Available sizes are 0-6 months pacifiers.
  • It has no color or chemical additions.
  • It’s the best baby teether with massaging effect on the gums of a teething baby.


What I love about it

  • It is non-toxic.
  • It’s soft thus safe for baby.
  • Easy to clean.
  • No choking hazard.


Something to keep in mind

  • Low durability hence requires replacement after 3 months.




4. Natursutten Pacifiers



Made in: Italy.

Natursutten pacifiers are from natural rubber; thus, no chemicals or color additions. Besides, it very soft than silicone, therefore safe for your baby face. It comes in one-piece design; hence no dirt accumulation maintaining high hygiene. Also, it’s free from BPA, phthalates and PVC.

  • It has no cracks to hide bacteria and dirt.
  • It comes in three sizes from 0-6 months, 6-12 months, and 12 months+.
  • Very soft.


What I love about it

  • Safe design for baby.
  • Has two models to choose from, that is orthodontic and round model.


Something to keep in mind

  • It requires frequent replacement every month.




5. Philips AVENT BPA Free Soothie Pacifier



Made in: USA.

It’s critical in hospitals to soothe newborns. The pacifier is for babies above 3 months and has no BPA content. Besides, it very easy to clean and sterilize being a dishwasher safe. It’s of high-quality silicone and orthodontic design for safety of baby gum and teeth.

  • Easy to clean and disinfect.
  • It comes in baby’s size and shapes for compatibility.
  • Very soft and suitable for teething.


What I love about it

  • Free from odors.
  • Very durable, having a firm nipple.


Something to keep in mind

  • It may be hard for a non-teething baby.




6. Ryan and Rose Cutie PAT Pacifier Grey Stage 1



Made in: china.

The pacifier is for baby without teeth. It has a soft nipple that resembles breasts thus more comfortable and soothing for baby. Besides, it long-lasting and easy to clean. It’s free from BPA, latex, phthalate, and PVC.

  • The pacifier has breathing holes, thus no risk on skin irritation on the baby.
  • It has a large shield that gives more chewing space to the baby.
  • Has no seam thus very durable.


What I love about it

  • It has a solid handle thus easy to hold.
  • It has a round soft nipple.


Something to keep in mind

  • It has a small nipple thus challenging to sustain it in baby’s mouth.




7. NUK Cute-as-a-Button Glow-in-The-Dark Orthodontic Pacifiers



Made in: USA.

This is another great option when it comes to the top organic pacifiers. It comes with a small orthodontic nipple that offers comfort while sucking. Besides, it prevents misalignment of teeth.

Moreover, its shape is like a natural mother’s nipple, thus no nipple confusion. Its shield has a heart shape. So, it fits well beneath the baby’s nose, allowing easy breathing. It’s easy to clean and dishwasher safe.

  • Suitable for babies between 0-6 months.
  • Easy to clean.
  • It comes in a pack of two pacifiers.


What I love about it

  • It has low pressure on teeth; thus, little chance of tooth misalignment.
  • No case of nipple confusion since its nipple resembles that of a mother.


Something to keep in mind

  • Expensive.




8. Nanobebe Pacifiers 0-3 Months



Made in: china.

It comes with an ergonomic design that is very light. Besides, the nipple is soft made from silicone hence soothing baby while sucking. It’s free from phthalate and BPA thus safe for the baby health.

  • It’s the best organic pacifier with soothing effect.
  • It prohibits cases of nipple confusion.
  • Very soft for baby comfort.
  • The one-piece design thus easy to clean.


What I love about it

  • It has a perfect fit in baby’s mouth.
  • It has no choking hazard.


Something to keep in mind

  • Expensive.




9. RaZbaby Razberry Silicone Baby Teether Toy



Made in: china.

This organic pacifier is excellent for a teething baby thus serves to relieve pain in the gums. Besides, it very easy to clean and has no choking hazard, although it may be huge for a baby mouth.

  • It is non-toxic and free from BPA.
  • It’s the best natural organic pacifier with soft silicone nipple.
  • It has a perfect texture to chew, thus soothing growing teeth.
  • Its size is excellent for a 3 months baby.


What I love about it

  • Free from flavors.
  • It’s powerful to withstand baby bites.


Something to keep in mind

  • This organic pacifier holes are significant accommodating baby figure which may be harmful.




10. WabbaNub Pacifier



Made in: China.

The frog design is perfect for a baby having small legs that are easy to hold. Besides, it’s from medical-grade silicone thus safe from toxic elements. It’s a one-piece pacifier, so, no cracks to harbour germs and dirt.

  • It’s the best organic pacifier for newborns without teeth.
  • The pacifier design is comfortable and soothing to the baby.
  • There is no fear of losing it since it stays near the baby’s mouth always.


What I love about it

  • Easy to wash.
  • Free from BPA.


Something to keep in mind

  • Not suitable for teething baby.




Best Pacifier for Breast-fed Babies

Tommee Tippee Closer to Nature Soother Day Time Pacifier- BPA-free, Breast-Like Shape



Made in: UK.

Tommee Tippee is the best organic pacifier with an ergonomic design. It perfectly soothes babies. Besides, there is no risk of choking. Its design prevents the baby from swallowing the pacifier.

  • It has a native soothing experience.
  • It has a soft silicone.
  • It’s natural and safe for baby health.
  • It has ventilation holes, thus no risk skin irritation.


What I love about it

  • No risk of nipple confusion.
  • Very easy to clean and sterilize.
  • Its shape allows for a smooth transition between feeds.


Something to keep in mind

  • If it comes in contact with meals, tooth decay occurs.
  • It has low durability demanding a monthly replacement for baby safety.




Best Organic Pacifier Clips

Pacifier clips are many with different attaching capacities on baby clothes. I find Mushie organic Pacifier Clips the best for my baby. They have soft silicone beads that massage his gum and offer teething relief. Besides, it’s capable of holding pacifiers close to the baby.


1. Ali+Oli Modern Pacifier Clip



Made in: China.

It is cheap and suitable for both newborns and toddlers. Besides, it comes in different color such that you match it with your baby outfit. The clip has a perfect length that maintains it near the baby and prevents a choking hazard.


What I love about it

  • It long enough for baby.
  • This organic pacifier is of high quality with silicone beads.
  • It easy to clean.


Something to keep in mind

  • It’s not safe for chewing.
  • The metal clip is not safe for the delicate baby skin.




2. Madeline’s Box Original Softy Braided Pacifier Clip



Made in: USA.


It comes in the original design and high quality for baby. Besides, it suitable for both baby toys and pacifiers. It’s free from toxic components like lead and BPA. Also, it is easy to wash with hands using warm and soapy water.

  • It has 5% spandex and 95% cotton.
  • Durable.
  • Compatible with any pacifier.


What I love about it

  • It comes in different colors.
  • It has a stylish design to soothe your baby.


Something to keep in mind

  • It has a choking hazard, thus not suitable for babies below 3 years.




3. Mushie Pacifier Clip Holder



Made in: USA.


The silicone beads are free from toxic components; thus, safe for your baby. Besides, the cleaning process is simple. You use your hands and soap, and that’s all.

  • It has a suitable length making sure the clip is near the baby always.
  • No choking hazard.
  • Silicone beads are 100% food grade.


What I love about it

  • Easy to clean.
  • It comes in stylish colours.
  • It has high-quality silicone.


Something to keep in mind

  • Not compatible with a dishwasher.





4. Ryan and Rose Mini Pacifier Clip



Made in: USA.


It functions as both clip and teether. The clip nylon cord has the perfect length for the baby. Thus, you can’t lose it. Besides, it has food-grade silicone beads, so safe from toxic components.

  • Easy to clean.
  • High quality.
  • Food grade silicone beads.
  • Multi-functioning.


What I love about it

  • It is the best organic pacifier clip.
  • Easy to attach to pacifiers.


Something to keep in mind

  • Its sturdy thus may be unpleasant for 1 month old baby.




5. Little Sprouts Pacifier Clip



Made in: China.


The little sprouts pacifier clip is comfortable and soothing to the baby. Besides, it’s free from PVC and BPA thus very safe for your baby.

  • It very strong and safe from toxic elements.
  • It’s effortless to attach on pacifiers, thus, no risk of losing them.
  • It has several beads that soothe the baby by messaging the gums.


What I love about it

  • It has non-porous silicone beads that don’t hold dirt.
  • Easy to clean and it’s free from rust.
  • Free from choking hazard.


Something to keep in mind

  • It’s very tight thus challenging to grab.




Organic Pacifier FAQs


When Should I Introduce Pacifier to Breast-Fed Babies?

Introduce a non-toxic pacifier after the proper establishment of breastfeeding. It should be likely after four weeks. Any attempt to use the pacifier earlier will cause nipple confusion. But, if you are not breastfeeding, introduce the pacifier more first and track your baby feedings.


How Many Organic Pacifiers Do I Need?

The sum of the best non-toxic and organic pacifiers to use depends on you. Like for me, I find it easy and comfortable to use one than a dozen. With one-piece, I usually keep it clean since I don’t have any other to use. Besides, some mothers require two, while others several pacifiers.


When Should I Replace an Organic Pacifier?

Replace a pacifier often for the safety of your baby. All natural pacifiers usually tear up demanding a quick replacement. When it starts fading color, developing holes and stretching of the nipple, it requires replacement. Besides, replace it if it starts sticking and loosens some parts.


What to Do If My Baby Won’t Take a Pacifier?

Although not common, some babies won’t accept pacifiers no matter the trial you make. But, this should not discourage you. You can also try to switch your breast to the best non-toxic and organic pacifier when the baby sleeps. If all this fail, the baby doesn’t like the pacifiers, thus change to another type.

Besides, you can also try non-toxic toys.


How Do I Wash an Organic Pacifier?

After using a pacifier, it becomes sticky and accumulates dirt. Thus, it needs thorough cleaning and sanitizing before your baby uses it again. You can use bottle sanitizer to clean and also sanitize the pacifier. Also, use boiling water and microwaveable sanitizers.


Do Pacifiers Cause Nipple Confusion?

Nipple confusion can occur depending on the time you introduce an organic pacifier to your baby. If you are breastfeeding your baby, take some weeks before using the pacifier. It also helps to establish breastfeeding properly. Some baby won’t have the nipple confusion, and in case it appears, try to introduce a bottle with similar nipple.


Are Pacifiers Bad for Baby Teeth?

Lengthy use of pacifiers leads to dental effects on your baby. Your baby is at risk of having abnormal development like poor alignment, bite problems, and crumbling of teeth. But if you stop the use of pacifiers at an early age, may prevent these dental problems.


When Should My Baby Wean from their Organic Pacifier?


When your baby is above one to two years old, he doesn’t require a pacifier. Note that if you continue giving them to your baby for a long time, you are exposing him to dental problems. Any teeth problem before two years is fixable naturally. So don’t endanger your baby’s teeth with lengthy use of pacifiers, even when you choose some of the best organic pacifiers.



Best Organic Pacifiers – A Final Word

Finally, make your baby happy. I find it so satisfying when I see my baby enjoying the sucking feeling of a pacifier. Besides, nothing that comforts a baby like the rubbing feel around his gums when he is teething. However, don’t go for any pacifier, but choose from the best organic pacifiers for your baby.

Avoid toxic pacifiers with BPA or phthalate since they are very harmful and may cause brain, teeth, and prostate glands defects. Besides choosing the best organic best organic pacifiers, also read about other non-toxic baby products such as non-toxic cribs, diapers and plan your baby budget well with this brilliant mom planner.


Shobita Ravichandran

Shobita Ravichandran


Shobita created Parenthood Guide in 2015 after she found out the hard way about toxins in many safe looking baby products. She's an architect, researcher, writer and mum of two strong-willed little humans. Ever since she found out she was pregnant, she has been extensively researching natural, safe, organic and non-toxic products for her children. Now she wants to take you along on this non-toxic journey and share her findings of the best and safest baby products out there.


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I Love

Best Mom Planner- daily life planner - mothers day

I Choose

Organic Baby Shop- Browse safe and chemical-free baby products

Know The Facts

Toxic Chemicals List- Know the facts

Don’t Miss Out

Some Great Advice

Positive Parenting

I Recommend